Whole House Rental

The historic Prairie Guest House sits on a farm-like setting on two-acres in Fishers, Indiana. Innkeepers John and Karen Newton are honored to receive the “Hoosier Hospitality Award” from the state of Indiana. Our spacious bed & breakfast features beautiful gardens, large native Indiana trees, a rustic barn, and an on-site yoga studio. The mid-1800’s Gothic farmhouse has nine large guest rooms, each with a private bath and lovely common areas to relax in. Whole house rental for your family and friends.

Across the courtyard, the early 1900’s cottage houses the kitchen and dining areas, where you will enjoy a fabulous home-cooked breakfast daily or relax in the cozy sunroom. When you’re ready for some activity, join a class in our yoga studio, venture across the street to explore Conner Prairie, head into a neighboring town for a meal and antique shopping, or take a walk in a nearby nature preserve. We’re located directly north of Indianapolis; within 35 minutes to downtown.

We would love to host your ReunionGirls Getaway, or Wedding Party. Contact us today fro more details and to reserve your very own guest house!

An Award Winning, Family Run Luxury Guest House

9 guest suites with 13 beds. Each suite has an adjoining private bathroom. Suites are furnished with dressers, closets, TV, and WiFi. We have roll-away beds available as well as Iron and Board.

– All 9 of our guest suites
– Delicious breakfast each morning 
– Fire Pit
– Use of our decks and patios

Event space and yoga studio rental are available for an additional fee.


Breakfast: served every morning so your gaggle can gather and share their plans for the day, and tell stories about what happened last night. We can set breakfast for the time of your choice. If your crew sleeps in we can fix it later, or if you all are going for an early morning canoe trip we can have breakfast at the break of dawn.

Full-house rental pricing for all nine rooms, sleeping up to 24 guests:

Weekday lodging (Sunday-Thursday): $2200 per night plus tax

Weekend lodging (Friday & Saturday): $3000 per night plus tax

The above rates include breakfast for every guest. Remember, reserve early to ensure you get all nine guest suites and a private breakfast to yourselves!

Give us a call at 317-663-8728, or email us at stay@prairieguesthouse.com to inquire about accommodations or events. All pricing is for 2022. Call for future pricing.

Floor Plan

Prairie Guest House Floorplan


Ready to start your adventure?